What is Joe's situation? Why does he compare it to drowning?
The first character we meet is Joe. He is on the verge of dying but hasn't yet. Joe has many memories and flashbacks during the first two chapters. He says that he is deaf and can't hear anymore then sates that he is getting his arm cut off. All of this relates to the story Joe told about drowning. The story was how someone couldn't drown. "He has been rising and sinking for days weeks months who could tell?" Joe has been on the verge of dying but hasn't yet. I get the impression that Joe wanted to die and get all of his pain over with. Since he is deaf and doesn't have arms he feels like death but just can't die just like trying to drown but can't. He remembers when Kareen asks for Joe to hug him but he gets upset because how is he supposed to hug her without any arms. In the first chapters we don't clearly know what is wrong Joe and why he is hurt but we have an idea that he was fighting in a war.
new asylum
Philomena Guinea paid for Esther to move to the private institution where she would now stay. This institution is completely different from the city institution. It was nice, there were maids and she even had a women doctor. Esther acts completely different at this new institution, I think, because she is treated as if she wasn’t crazy. Doctor Nolan asked Esther about Doctor Gordon. Esther tells her that she didn’t like him because of what he did to her. Doctor Nolan assures Esther that if they ever do something like the shock treatments, that she will feel no pain and will no regret getting them done. Esther new doctor tells her that shock treatments are not meant to be bad like Esther experienced. I think that if she would have stayed in the city institution, she would have really gone crazy. Esther is getting better and even moves from Wymark to Caplan. This is proof that she is getting better being in the new institution. I do not think she would have improved her health if she didn’t switch into the private institution.
13-14
What is wrong with Esther? Why does she try to kill herself?
Esther has had problems ever since she has come home from New York. I believe that there are many reasons why Esther tried to kill herself. Everything is pilling up and she just can't take it anymore. She knows that she has problems but doesn't want to go back to shock therapy. This I think is Dr. Gordon's fault because he doesn't really try to talk it out with Esther. She tries to commit suicide multiple times, but doesn't succeed or doesn't follow through completely. The last time that she attempted to commit suicide was when she overdosed on an abundance of sleeping pills. Esther tries to kill herself because she doesn't have a place, no real friends, or even a mother who is there for her.
Esther has had problems ever since she has come home from New York. I believe that there are many reasons why Esther tried to kill herself. Everything is pilling up and she just can't take it anymore. She knows that she has problems but doesn't want to go back to shock therapy. This I think is Dr. Gordon's fault because he doesn't really try to talk it out with Esther. She tries to commit suicide multiple times, but doesn't succeed or doesn't follow through completely. The last time that she attempted to commit suicide was when she overdosed on an abundance of sleeping pills. Esther tries to kill herself because she doesn't have a place, no real friends, or even a mother who is there for her.
Dr. Gordon
Why doesn’t Esther like Dr. Gordon? Is he hurting or helping her?
Esther has gone crazy and decides (knows) that she needs to get help from a psychiatrist. Before she met him she thinks that he is conceited. She sees a picture of the perfect family in his office and this bothers her even more I think because it is something that she doesn't have. Dr. Gordon asks her on page 129, "Suppose you try and tell me what you think is wrong". This bothers Esther because she knows she has a problem and she wants to get help. I feel like Dr. Gordon gave up too easily. He told Esther to come back next week for her next session but decides to do shock therapy. I don't agree with his decision because I think he should of talked to her a little longer. I think that the shock therapy hurt her because she goes even more crazy than she already is.
Esther has gone crazy and decides (knows) that she needs to get help from a psychiatrist. Before she met him she thinks that he is conceited. She sees a picture of the perfect family in his office and this bothers her even more I think because it is something that she doesn't have. Dr. Gordon asks her on page 129, "Suppose you try and tell me what you think is wrong". This bothers Esther because she knows she has a problem and she wants to get help. I feel like Dr. Gordon gave up too easily. He told Esther to come back next week for her next session but decides to do shock therapy. I don't agree with his decision because I think he should of talked to her a little longer. I think that the shock therapy hurt her because she goes even more crazy than she already is.
Chapter 9 and 10
How does Esther act when she returns to Boston? How might her night with Marco have influenced her actions?
To me Marco is a jerk, he expected to get sex out of Esther. Marco gives Esther his diamond pin and now he also expects to have Esther dance with him. He tells her to act like she is drowning so that he can take control of the dancing. He then attempts to rape her, but Esther almost lets him do it so she can experience sex. When Marco calls her a slut she realizes that isn't what she wanted. Esther then punches Marco and his nose starts to bleed. Marco smears the blood on her face. Esther doesn't want to take off the blood from her face because it shows that she did something to someone, made damage. When Esther gets home to Boston she gets even more depressed. Her mother tells her that she didn't get accepted into the writing class that she applies for. It seems that she is more upset about this than almost getting raped by Marco. All of these things that have hurt her in New York had pilled up and she finally realized how broken apart she is.
To me Marco is a jerk, he expected to get sex out of Esther. Marco gives Esther his diamond pin and now he also expects to have Esther dance with him. He tells her to act like she is drowning so that he can take control of the dancing. He then attempts to rape her, but Esther almost lets him do it so she can experience sex. When Marco calls her a slut she realizes that isn't what she wanted. Esther then punches Marco and his nose starts to bleed. Marco smears the blood on her face. Esther doesn't want to take off the blood from her face because it shows that she did something to someone, made damage. When Esther gets home to Boston she gets even more depressed. Her mother tells her that she didn't get accepted into the writing class that she applies for. It seems that she is more upset about this than almost getting raped by Marco. All of these things that have hurt her in New York had pilled up and she finally realized how broken apart she is.
Chapter 7 and 8
What does Esther want from Constantin? How does he react? What do you think of his reaction?
Esther goes to the UN with Constantin. She is impressed with the foreign language that Constantin works with. This makes her think about all the stuff she can't do, which leads to the fig tree. The fig tree is something that represents marriage and children. Esther wants to have sex with Constantin to get back at Buddy, but they don't, they just lay in bed together after the UN. This makes Esther feel a lot better about herself. The fact that they do not have sex means that Constantin cares about Esther and just doesn't want to have sex with her. This to me means that Constantin is interested in forming a relationship. There were hints that Constantin likes Esther but it is not for certain.
Esther goes to the UN with Constantin. She is impressed with the foreign language that Constantin works with. This makes her think about all the stuff she can't do, which leads to the fig tree. The fig tree is something that represents marriage and children. Esther wants to have sex with Constantin to get back at Buddy, but they don't, they just lay in bed together after the UN. This makes Esther feel a lot better about herself. The fact that they do not have sex means that Constantin cares about Esther and just doesn't want to have sex with her. This to me means that Constantin is interested in forming a relationship. There were hints that Constantin likes Esther but it is not for certain.
Chapters 5 and 6
What does Esther think of Buddy? What does she want from him? What does she want him to think of her?
Esther liked Buddy a lot until she found out that he was having an affair with a waitress. Buddy is a science kind of guy, which is the opposite of Esther. Esther is enjoys literature. At first Buddy didn't let her talk about literature but then he asked her if she would read to him so that he could understand where she was coming from. Buddy got Esther to think that he was inexperienced, when really he was having an affair. Esther was upset when she found this out because she wanted to know the truth in the first place. Buddy tells Esther that he still has strong feelings for and even takes his clothes off but Esther didn't feel comfortable enough to take hers off. This shows that Esther doesn't have the same feelings for Buddy as he does for her.
Esther liked Buddy a lot until she found out that he was having an affair with a waitress. Buddy is a science kind of guy, which is the opposite of Esther. Esther is enjoys literature. At first Buddy didn't let her talk about literature but then he asked her if she would read to him so that he could understand where she was coming from. Buddy got Esther to think that he was inexperienced, when really he was having an affair. Esther was upset when she found this out because she wanted to know the truth in the first place. Buddy tells Esther that he still has strong feelings for and even takes his clothes off but Esther didn't feel comfortable enough to take hers off. This shows that Esther doesn't have the same feelings for Buddy as he does for her.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)